The long, painful case over the death of Elkview man John Lucas is getting a new prosecutor, and folks in Kanawha County should expect it to take a little longer to reach its next chapter.
Kanawha County Circuit Judge Dave Hardy on Thursday granted Prosecuting Attorney Debra Rusnak's request to step aside from the case against Alyssa Middleton, the former Kanawha County EMT accused of striking Lucas with the ambulance she was driving in April and dragging him beneath it for close to two miles. Middleton faces charges of voluntary manslaughter, aggravated vehicular homicide, and leaving the scene of a fatal crash. She has not been convicted, and the charges remain allegations.
Why the Prosecutor Asked to Step Aside
Rusnak first asked to be disqualified last month. As we reported then, the motion initially went to the chief judge, who ruled it had to be heard by Judge Hardy, the judge presiding over the criminal case. Thursday's hearing was that next step.
In court, Rusnak told the judge she no longer believes she can handle the case properly. She pointed to a breakdown in communication with the Lucas family, threats she says were made against herself, Middleton, and investigators, and the intense reaction to the case online. As an Elkview resident, she said, she knows family and friends on both sides, and she described being caught between two groups of very upset people while trying to stay neutral.
"I am simply at a point where I am unable to fulfill my obligations," Rusnak told the court.
Her executive assistant also testified about a tense encounter with a member of the Lucas family following an earlier hearing. Those accounts come from the prosecutor's side, and the Lucas family has previously disputed parts of how the prosecutor has described them.
What Happens Now
With Rusnak off the case, the West Virginia Prosecuting Attorneys Institute will appoint a special prosecutor from another county to take it over.
Judge Hardy was direct about what that means for the timeline. A new prosecutor will need time to learn a case like this from the ground up, and he said there was no question it will slow things down.
A status hearing is still on the calendar for November 30, but the judge said it could be pushed back depending on when the special prosecutor is named.
A Community Still Waiting
Few cases have stirred up Kanawha County like this one. Since April, it has drawn protests, packed courtrooms, and strong feelings all across the Elk River valley. For the Lucas family, Thursday's ruling means more waiting. For everyone following along, it's a reminder that the courts still have plenty of work ahead before this case is settled.
We'll keep following the case and let you know once a special prosecutor is appointed and a new hearing date is set.