Up in Marion County, the little town of Worthington is at the center of a fight over whether it should keep existing as a town at all, and now that fight has landed in front of the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals.
Former Worthington Mayor Deborah Heflin filed a petition for a writ of mandamus on Tuesday against the Marion County Commission, its three commissioners and the Town of Worthington. She is asking the justices to order the commission to hold a hearing and issue a written decision on her request to dissolve the town's charter, and she asked the court to take the case up on an expedited basis.
Eight Votes
Heflin first brought her petition to the county commission on August 5. It leans on a state law that lists fewer than 20 legal votes in a municipality's last election as grounds for a town to forfeit its charter. According to her filing, only eight votes were cast in Worthington's June 2025 municipal election, and she included the election result in the paperwork she submitted to the court.
Her complaint is that the commission has never acted. She says it has held no hearing and made no decision, and she argues state law requires the commission to decide whether a petition like hers is sufficient within a reasonable amount of time.
Importantly, Heflin is not asking the Supreme Court to decide whether Worthington should be dissolved. Her filing only asks the justices to make the county commission do its part and rule on the petition one way or the other.
What the County Has Said
The commission acknowledged receiving the petition at its August 12 meeting. Minutes from that meeting, included in the court filing, show the county administrator said no action would be taken at that time, and one commissioner said the commission would ultimately judge the petition and should not comment or offer advice until a hearing was held.
Worthington's recorder and acting mayor, Melvin Lindsey, said the town had no comment on Heflin's petition. He pointed residents instead to a public meeting on the town's sanitary sewer facility plan, set for Monday, Nov. 16, from 6 to 8 p.m. at the Worthington Volunteer Fire Department, where people are encouraged to share their comments.
A Long-Running Sewer Problem
Sewer troubles sit underneath much of this story. Worthington's system has struggled for years, including raw sewage overflows during heavy rain. A proposal to swap the aging vacuum system for a gravity system was previously estimated to cost between $30 million and $40 million, a staggering figure for a town that counted 183 residents in the 2020 census.
Heflin, who resigned as mayor in July, has also asked the state Public Service Commission to declare Worthington's sewer system a distressed utility. In September, PSC staff recommended dismissing that petition, and Heflin has asked the commission to reject that recommendation.
For now, folks along U.S. Route 19 in Worthington are waiting to see whether the state's highest court will push the county to settle a question few West Virginia towns ever have to face: whether their town should go on being a town.