Friday, November 20, 2026
Breaking
community

Thurmond Sues the National Park Service to Stop Demolition of 12 Historic Buildings

The tiny Fayette County railroad town filed a federal lawsuit asking a judge to halt National Park Service plans to tear down 12 buildings in or near Thurmond ahead of a roughly $36 million project set to start in early December.

West Virginia Pulse Staff ·
Thurmond Sues the National Park Service to Stop Demolition of 12 Historic Buildings
A row of weathered red brick commercial buildings beside railroad tracks and the New River in a steep, wooded West Virginia gorge

One of the smallest towns in West Virginia is taking on the federal government to save its past. The Town of Thurmond in Fayette County filed a federal lawsuit on Wednesday, Nov. 18, asking a judge to stop the National Park Service from tearing down 12 buildings in or near town.

Thurmond sits deep inside New River Gorge National Park and Preserve, and those old structures are a big part of what makes a visit there feel like stepping back a century.

What the Park Service has planned

The Park Service is close to starting a project worth roughly $36 million to improve infrastructure around Thurmond. According to the agency, that work includes restoring some historic buildings and demolishing others, and it is expected to begin in early December. The Park Service is already accepting proposals to lease three historic buildings in the park.

What the town is arguing

The lawsuit says that for decades the Park Service promised to preserve, rehabilitate and reuse Thurmond's buildings as a gateway for heritage tourism, then let them fall apart. The town's main points:

  • The Park Service did not properly consider leasing the buildings as an alternative to demolition.
  • Former owners sold their properties to the Park Service believing the structures would be preserved.
  • The town never received complete demolition plans.
  • The town was not given the full 30 days to review a revised schedule, as required under a Programmatic Agreement.
  • Consultation on mitigation was never finished.

Thurmond is asking the court to halt the demolitions, require the Park Service to complete its review and consultation, and take a fresh look at options like leasing. Filing the lawsuit does not, by itself, stop the work. That decision rests with the judge.

The buildings on the line

The structures named include the Prince Brothers General Store, the McGuffin Garage, the Harold Smith House, the May Bagoski House and the James Humphrey Sr. House, among others.

A local preservation group, Preservation Thurmond, wants the buildings leased and put back to work, imagining something like a coffee shop or a bike shop for the visitors who already come through the gorge, rather than seeing them torn down.

A railroad boomtown with a big story

Thurmond was incorporated in 1903 and grew into a busy railroad boomtown, with more than 400 people living there in the 1930s. When the railroads switched from steam to diesel, the town's fortunes faded. The 2020 census counted just five residents.

Thurmond has been on the National Register of Historic Places since 1984, and its old depot now serves as a park visitor center. For a lot of West Virginians, Thurmond is living proof of how much history can fit in one narrow ledge between the tracks and the river.

We'll keep an eye on the case and let you know what the court decides before demolition is set to begin.

Keep exploring

You're In!

Welcome to the WV Pulse community.

Be on the lookout for our next edition in your inbox. We deliver the top West Virginia stories and events every morning.

Check your inbox

Add us to your contacts so we don't end up in spam.