
There's now a date on the calendar in the case that has the whole Mountain State talking. West Virginia State Auditor Mark Hunt is scheduled to make his first appearance in federal court on Monday, Nov. 30, the first workday after the Thanksgiving holiday weekend.
According to the federal court calendar for the Southern District of West Virginia, Hunt's initial appearance and arraignment is set for 2 p.m. in Charleston before U.S. Magistrate Judge Dwane L. Tinsley. U.S. District Judge Thomas E. Johnston is assigned to the case.
Five back-to-back hearings
Hunt won't be the only one in the courtroom that afternoon. The court has lined up a run of hearings for everyone charged in the two indictments handed up on Nov. 16:
- 1:30 p.m. – David Keith Cole, deputy chief of staff in the auditor's office
- 2 p.m. – State Auditor Mark A. Hunt
- 2:30 p.m. – Frederic Scott Caudill, the office's general counsel
- 3 p.m. – Robert Lisle Johns, a Charleston attorney who works as special counsel for the office
- 3:30 p.m. – Marie Ann Hoffmann, an auditor's office employee
An arraignment is the first formal step in a federal criminal case. The judge reads or explains the charges, the defendant enters a plea, and the court sets conditions of release.
What the case is about
Federal prosecutors allege Hunt overruled career employees in the auditor's Land Division and signed deeds for nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties that staff had found were not eligible, benefiting a business tied to Johns. Hunt, Cole, Caudill and Johns each face nine counts of theft of property, and Caudill and Cole are also charged with making false statements to federal investigators.
A second indictment charges Hunt, Cole and Hoffmann with bank fraud. Prosecutors allege Hoffmann's state timecards counted hours she spent doing work for Hunt's private law firm.
Pressure is building in Charleston
The court date comes on top of a fast-moving week at the Capitol. House Speaker Roger Hanshaw has called on Hunt to resign and said the House would take swift action in January if he doesn't. Gov. Patrick Morrisey has asked the House to consider articles of impeachment and has sent a separate state DMV review of Hunt's used-car dealership to federal prosecutors. Hunt has said he plans to keep serving while the matter is resolved in court.
The state auditor keeps watch over how state money is spent and runs the sale of tax-delinquent land, so this is a case that reaches into every one of West Virginia's 55 counties. It's worth remembering that an indictment is only an accusation. Hunt and the others are presumed innocent unless they are proven guilty in court.
We'll be watching on Nov. 30 and will share what happens as soon as we know. You can catch up on our earlier coverage of the federal indictment and the governor's impeachment call.