The long-running fight over who should hold a Berkeley County seat in the West Virginia House of Delegates has hit a wall at the state's highest court. On Friday, the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia denied a challenge brought by state Democratic Party Chairman Mike Pushkin and Stephen Willingham over the appointment of Republican Ian Masters to the District 91 seat.
To understand how we got here, you have to go back to the 2024 election. Joseph de Soto won the District 91 seat as a Republican that November. Shortly before he was arrested the following month and charged with making threats to harm or kill Republican lawmakers, he switched his party registration to Democrat.

On Jan. 8, 2025, the House of Delegates passed a resolution declaring the seat vacant. The resolution pointed to de Soto's home confinement and to at least two protective orders lawmakers had obtained barring him from the Capitol, conditions the House said would keep him from taking the oath of office there as required. The vacancy then went to the Berkeley County Republican Executive Committee to send nominees to Gov. Patrick Morrisey, who appointed Masters on Jan. 23, 2025.
Democrats argued that state law at the time required the replacement to come from the Democratic Party, since de Soto was registered as a Democrat before the seat came open. They asked the court to step in against House Speaker Roger Hanshaw and the governor.
The justices didn't reach that question. Writing for the court, Chief Justice Haley Bunn said the Democrats lacked standing because the harm they claimed couldn't be fixed by the court. The court found it could not order Speaker Hanshaw to seat de Soto, and because no vacancy exists with Masters already in the seat, it could not compel the governor to appoint a Democrat from a list of nominees either.
"We find that, under the circumstances of this case, this Court cannot order either Respondent to carry out these actions, and accordingly, the Petitioners' purported injury is not redressable," Bunn wrote in the court's opinion. Justice Bill Wooton filed a separate opinion in the case.
For now, the ruling leaves Masters right where he is, representing District 91 in the House of Delegates, and closes another chapter in one of the stranger political sagas the Mountain State has seen in years.