Families who sue West Virginia's jails and prisons after a loved one dies behind bars just lost one of their most important legal arguments.
In a 3-2 decision released Thursday, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals ruled that a Kanawha County circuit judge made a legal mistake by letting "deliberate indifference" claims move forward in two lawsuits against the state Division of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
What "Deliberate Indifference" Means
A deliberate indifference claim argues that jail or prison staff knew an inmate was in danger or seriously ill and chose to do nothing about it. Lawsuits built on that argument against the corrections division have ended in settlements and courtroom wins in the past.
Writing for the majority, Justice H.L. Kirkpatrick said the court has never formally recognized deliberate indifference as its own cause of action under state common law, and that doing so would make West Virginia an outlier, possibly the only state to allow it. Justices Haley Bunn and Charles Trump joined him. Justices Bill Flanigan and Bill Wooton dissented.
The court issued writs of prohibition, orders telling the lower court it had overstepped, in both cases. The practical effect is that families and inmates can no longer bring deliberate indifference as a standalone claim when seeking damages in state court, although the justices stopped short of permanently ruling it out.
The Two Cases
Both lawsuits involve people who died while held in West Virginia's regional jails. One centers on Jacquline Pyles, 24, who was found dead in her cell at the North Central Regional Jail in 2021; she had a documented history of mental health conditions on file there. The other involves Ronald Marvin Myers, 79, who died after, according to his family's attorneys, he went without medical care for several conditions while held at the Eastern Regional Jail.
Why It Matters
West Virginia's jails have faced years of scrutiny over deaths in custody, staffing shortages and conditions. Thursday's ruling narrows one path families have used to hold the state accountable in court, and the split decision shows the justices themselves were divided on the issue.