West Virginia's top election official wants both major parties playing by the same rules the next time voters head to the polls for a primary.
Secretary of State Kris Warner said this week that the Republican and Democratic parties should use matching rules for primary elections, after this year's split approach led to confusion and two legal challenges.
Two Parties, Two Sets of Rules
In the May primary, the state Republican Party closed its ballot to unaffiliated voters, while Democrats kept allowing unaffiliated voters to ask for a Democratic ballot. Warner's office said it was the first time in decades that the two parties had operated under different primary rules.
According to the Secretary of State's Office, that difference led directly to two court challenges. In Fayette County, the result of a party executive committee race was thrown out after a challenge over unaffiliated voters casting Republican ballots, and that race was ordered onto the November general election ballot. A second challenge, brought by a legislative candidate in Harrison County, was settled without a new election.
Warner said the mismatched rules also created administrative headaches and left some voters and poll workers confused about who could vote in which primary.
Low Turnout
The May primary drew 252,008 voters out of nearly 1.2 million registered, a turnout of about 21%. Preliminary figures put turnout for the November general election at 38.3%, which Warner's office described as the lowest for a midterm in more than a decade. Warner suggested the differing primary rules may have played a part in keeping some voters home.
How It Could Be Fixed
Warner said there are two ways to get to a uniform system: the Republican Party could revisit its own primary rules, or state lawmakers could settle the question by changing state law. Either way, he said, West Virginia needs one consistent standard to protect confidence in its elections.
Apart from the primary-rules issue, Warner said this month's midterm went very well by most election-integrity measures. His office plans to release a full report on the general election.